Comments

Comment by 1437

Especially good for healers who spam short cast spells (ie Priest w/ Flash Heal, Tree Druid spamming HoTs). Damage classes can normally find something better for their trinket slots and since it is a % on cast healers who primarily use long heals will not benefit nearly as much.

Comment by dcsn

Lets say spam of Heal Rank 2, 2.5s cast.
100 heals will occur in 250 seconds.
It has a 2% proc rate, so in 250s it will proc 2 times.
1 proc will give you 100% regen rate inside 5 seconds rule.
Lets say you regen in5sr is X and out5sr is Y
The real gain will be Y-X
so you will get Y-X and will multiply for 7.5s (15s = 7.5 ticks)
Example
in5sr tick 50
out5sr tick 100
100-50 = 50
50*7.5 = 375mana per proc
it has a 2 procs every 250s spaming heal rank2.
or 375*2=750 mana in 250s or 4min and 10seconds.
shard of scale gives you 16mp5s, or 16/5=3.2 mp1s or 16/5*2=6.4mana per tick
in the 250s, the shard of onyxia would give you 250*3.2 = 800 mana.
mindtap talisman = 11mp5s = 2.2mp1s = 550mp250s

for a 250s time:
darkmoon card: blue dragon = 750 mana (with in5sr tick 50 and out5sr tick 100)
shard of scale = 800 mana
mindtap talisman = 550

Comment by 4336

That's some fine calculations you have there. However, I have some comments. >:D

The proc rate over a time span of 250 sec and 100 heals is 2.5. This makes more sence in theory, since the chance for the card to proc gets bigger as you use more spells. It's just like the 7.5 ticks over 15 sec, because here, you don't know if the card procs before or after a tick.

I got confused reading about X, Y, in5sr and the numbers 100 and 50. I couldn't make sence of them, and I didn't want to waste any more time looking at them. Here's my take on the situation:

A priest/mage with 250 spirit will regenerate 75 mana/tick. The other mana classes will regenerate 65 mana/tick (http://www.wowwiki.com/Formulas:Mana_Regen)

2.5 procs * 7.5 ticks * 75 mana = 1406 mana - priest/mage
2.5 procs * 7.5 ticks * 65 mana = 1219 mana - all the others

There you have it. This is for a player with 250 spirit at 100% mana regeneration. I don't think mana regeneration can stack to more than 100%, if you have talents plus the card and what ever. Keep in mind that this is for constantly casting a 2.5 sec spell over a period of 4 min and 10 sec. Taking breaks and casting longer spells will reduce the chance of a proc.

Comment by 3118

This is the only Darkmoon card that will scale well at 70 and beyond. Get your cards/deck now while people are still farming the instances, as soon as BC comes out prices will rise OR the cards will just never show up. % based items are the only ones that will still pull their weight at 70.

Comment by 8765

At one point in time this card used to proc off of wanding and creating tradeskill items. It aslo used to stack with the 15% meditation and 3 piece transcendence bonuses, so you'd get 130% mana regeneration for the duration of the proc if you had both bonuses. Now, however, none of these work. If it procs, you get 100% mana regneration for the 15 seconds and that's it.

People most compare it to the Mindtap Talisman out of DM West. The general rule of thumb is if you have 300+ spirit that this card pulls ahead over the long term. Be aware though that the % chance nature of this card makes it unreliable in that regard. Assuming Spirit levels rise with The Burning Crusade release, I expect this card to be much better long-term than the Mindtap Talisman.

It should be noted that there are a few ways to take full advantage of this trinket. If you do no casting after it procs, you're really only getting 5 seconds of "benefit" out of the proc. That is not to say that you should just cast spells for the sake of casting them, but if anyone needs their health topped off now is the time to do it. Also, if you finish a spell just before the effect ends, you don't go into the 5 second rule afterward so you're effectively extending the benefit of this trinket. This trinket is also considered an excellent choice for people who are on decursing duties during boss fights.

Comment by 9590

This is a very useful item for casters in my opinion. It can really help in a pinch in boss fights in endgame instances. If you have the money or are willing to farm for it, definitely go for it.

Comment by 25099

I always hated this thing on my Priest. In fact, I totally gave up and ended up vendoring it for a few gold when TBC hit. I just found it far to random, it would proc when I didn't need it, and when it would have been life saving it never happend. Thats fine and dandy for a DPS class, but for a healer I need reliability and consistency, not unpredictability. I went with a pair of "lesser" trinkets, that give me reliable regen.

Comment by 37437

The ability to upgrade these decks, or possibly the just the cards, has just been released. This is however due to come in patch 2.1.

http://www.worldofwarcraft.com/patchnotes/test-realm-patchnotes.html

I'm awaiting what they will be like.

Comment by TyrionFarseer

Even at level 70 this trinket is very strong for a healer. A priest stacking spirit can easily regenerate over 1500 mana from a proc of Blue Dragon.

Notably, this trinket scales with the rest of your gear, and also benefits from raid buffs (DS, Kings...). Pre-TBC I had over 600 spirit on my priest fully buffed making this trinket a veritable powerhouse - especially on fights where I was decursing.

The trouble is making spirit work for you. You have to really pay attention to the 5-second rule, and heal in bursts.

I'm yet to see a better mana-regen trinket for healers in long fights.

Comment by 51934

I have that trink and usually (always) use it on boss fights and I'm doing damn good. In Gruul's Lair. I'm at 500+ mp5 so having that full mp5 during 15sec gives me back 1500 mana + (that doesnt count BoW). The only thing that I wonder now is : Card > https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=28823#M0z cause once I find out what's the best. I'll either keep DKP or spend them on the eye.

Comment by 57779

From a stylish point of view, this trinket goes very well with this earring.
https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=30665

Rogues drool over big hitting onehanders.
This combo is what a priest drools over. Yes, we're sad.
But we're sad with full 0-100% mana in less than 20 seconds with this.

Comment by 77243

I was thinking about getting this for my hunter. Has anybody tried it yet? Will the shots count as spells?

Comment by 15927

Quick and dirty comparison from a ToL-Druids perspective, but useful for priests as well.

General assumptions:
- You are a druid, therefore your mana gained every 2s-tick is: spirit/4.5+15 (according to wowwiki) (priests: spirit/4+12.5)
- You got 600 spirit with raid-buffs. (I usually have around 700.)
- You have 3/3 Intensity.
- During the fight, you are always in the five-second-rule (5SR.
- You cast 15 spells per minute. (approx. castrate if you keep Rejuvenation and 3x Lifebloom on a single target)
------------------------------------------

Eye of Gruul https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=28823
* no internal cooldown assumed
* You make full effect of the proc by saving the full 450 mana.
15 (casts) * 0.02 (procrate) * 450 (mana) / 12 = 135 mana/min = 11.25 mp5
------------------------------------------

Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=19288
* no internal cooldown assumed
* possibility of procs while the buff is up ignored (highly unlikely)

additional mana per proc = 600/4.5+15 (spirit based mana regen per 2s tick)/2 * 15 (sec duration) * 0.85 (difference from 3/3 intensity) = 1087 mana
15 (casts) * 0.02 (procrate) * 1087 mana = 326 mana/min = 27 mp5
------------------------------------------

Bangle of Endless Blessings https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=28370
* 10% procrate
* internal cooldown capping the ppm at around 1

additional mana per proc = 600/4.5+15 (spirit based mana regen per 2s tick)/2 * 15 (sec duration) * 0.15 (additional spirit based mana regen) = 192 mana
15 (casts) * 0.1 (procrate) = 1.5 ppm but due to cap: 1 * 192 mana = 192 mana/min = 27 mp5 = 16 mp5

* Use effect: Innervate yourself with macro while buff is up. 1 time in 10 minute fight. Any other uses ignored. (!!!) Also I have not checked if you get bonus spirit on the buff from Living Spirit:
130/4.5 (spirit mana regen per 2 sec)/2 * 20 (sec duration) * 5 (innervate) = 1444 mana

1444 mana/10min = 144 mana/min = 12 mp5 (so 28mp5 together)
------------------------------------------

Summary:
Eye of Gruul: 11.25 mp5 (maximum effect!)
Blue Dragon : 27 mp5
Bangle of Endless Blessings: 28 mp5 (combined effects)
(15 casts/min)

Eye of Gruul: 30 mp5 (Rejuvenation Rank 13 spam in Treeform > only saving 332 mana per proc = 22 mp5)
Blue Dragon : 72 mp5 (since ppm is still only 0.8 buffs not overlaying is save to assume)
Bangle of Endless Blessings: 28 mp5 (capped ppm)
(40 casts/min - instants)
------------------------------------------

Pitfalls of this comparison:
* On one hand I assumed that you are in the 5SR throughout the fight, which is likely not the case. Of course spirit-based mana regen recovery through Blue Dragon and BoEB shines in this scenario. On the other hand one can argue that parts of a fight in which you are often not in the 5SR, are not that crucial anyway (from a healers perspective) and having 600 spirit will help you out there.
* This comparison is more useful for fights (or phases of fights) in which you put out some serious healing likely using Regrowth as well. That's why I assumed the maximum effect on the Eye (HT/Regrowth-Spam). If it makes a 100something mana cast a free cast the effect is greatly diminished. (!!!)
* I assumed non-overlapping buffs. This would be harder to model, but would lead to a problem only with the Blue Dragon-Card, due to the internal CD of BoEB and consumption of the buff by the next cast with the Eye of Gruul.
* You will be able to use the "Use" on BoEB a couple of times in a fight. You might innervate other players.

But still: Different strokes for different folks!

Comment by Krios

I'm a Balance druid with DS/Intensity, I use the BoEB for fights I know that are going to really tax my longevity, (always trying to prove I'm not an oomkin) and I am wondering if perhaps this trinket might be better for me.

I know that the proc rates are about the same for each and that this trinket gives 100% vs the BoEB's 15%, but with the bangle's use feature I can innervate myself for a big boost.

I really only find myself in a bind on fights where people have died mid way through the fight and I need to boost my dps and ignore conservation. I stack alot of int/mp5 gems and favor gear with heavy int and mp5.

Comment by 22868

I would say if you have over 650 spirit fully raid buffed, the bangle isn't going to add anything to your innervate because the amount of spirit you have will top off your entire mana bar from 1-2K to full on its own.

that being said, this trinket is just awesome for tree druids, specifically those tree druids who spend alot of their time in the MT group.

I have 809 spirit fully raid buffed, and after 2.3, will have 889ish. i have 676 mp5 while not casting, which puts this trinket at 2028 mana per proc for me.

Last night, about 3.5 hours of raiding, it procc'd 29 times, giving me approximately 58812 extra mana. Eye of Gruul doesn't even come close to comparing to it with the way I'm itemized.

For example, during a 13 minute Alar fight, it procced 6 times, giving me 12168 mana, or 936 per minute, or 78 mp5.

And it just scales up from there!

Comment by 70576

There's hardly need for more calculations to prove to me the point that this is a great trinket for ambitious tree druids. I really want it for my druid.

The problem that no one is discussing here is how to actually get it, assuming you weren't around pre-TBC. The required Ace of Beasts has, according to this website, a 5% chance to drop off the Beast, a boss in Upper Blackrock Spire. To even get there you need the Seal of Ascension, a key rewarded by a lengthy quest involving bosses inside Lower Blackrock Spire and a dragon boss in Dustwallow Marsh. The quest could reasonably be soloed by some 70's, particularly if they have stealth.

If you hope to buy the Ace of Beasts on AH or trade channel, consider all the things that need to come together for that to happen: A group (at the very best as few as two 70's with stealth I would think), already having access to UBRS, enter and kill the Beast... it then drops the actual Ace of Beasts... that is then looted by someone who isn't going to use it himself or trade it to a friend or guildie... that player posts it on AH or trade channel... then by a miracle you happen to be online at the right time to have a chance to buy the card off that player... and you have the gold to pay whatever price he sets up...

As you can see the odds must be tragically low.

The other option then is to take matters into your own hands and farm the Beast until you get the coveted Darkmoon card. Let's say you convince a friend or guildie to help you with this and you complete the Seal of Ascension quest in an hour or two then start making your way to the boss. You're then faced with a drop rate which may be as low as 5% (according to Wowhead data)...

Well you can see where I'm going with this. New acquisitions of this card are probably very very rare now with TBC. Do not buy any of the other Beasts cards unless you get the Ace first by some miracle. If you're crazy enough to farm the boss, bring an enchanter if possible to DE all the blues you'll loot...

Comment by 55393

too many goddamned calculations.
it will proc when it wants to

Comment by 22868

Scam 2 other guildies (preferably some kind of rogue/mage combo) into farming it with you. You can probably entice them with promises of large brilliant shards, hehe. Had my spouse not found the entire deck on the AH two or three days before the weekend, this is what I had planned to do.

You can three man farm it easily with the right combo.

Comment by 24604

I have 809 spirit fully raid buffed, and after 2.3, will have 889ish. i have 676 mp5 while not casting, which puts this trinket at 2028 mana per proc for me.

What you did is: mp5 while not casting * 3 = mana gained from proc. That's not correct though. Your total mp5 is made up of spirit based mp5 and non-spirit based mp5. The non-spirit based mp5 is always active, whether this trinket procs or not. So all you'll gain when this trinket procs is spirit based mp5. And then only 70% of it because you already get 30% all the time from intensity. So what you gain with 809 spirit and 1 proc is:

spirit based mana per second * 70% * 15 seconds
or
(809/4.5 +15)/2 * 0.7 *15 = 1023 mana from one proc.

Or is the case of your Al'ar fight: 6 * 1023 / (13 * 60/5) = 39 mp5

Still very good though and almost the same as Alchemist's Stone which gives 40 mp5 max when using super mana pots.

Comment by 97596

I'm an arcane mage and as far as most arcane mages go, we burn arcane blast to maximize dps due to the low threat produced, which therefore saps mana like crazy. I raid with 2 mana regen trinkets (which works out to be better damage than 2 damage trinkets)
https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=24127
and this one. but now that
https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=35703
has come out, looks like i'll be retiring this trinket : ( it's served me really well though.
Probably doesn't work so well on arcane mages compared to other classes coz due to Arcane Meditation (30% mana regen while casting) and Mage Armor (another 30%) this trinket effectively only adds 40% mana regen when it procs. I worked it out and got only 291 mana when it procs (assumed to be once every 3 minutes or so) which works out to be ~8mp5, compared to 43 and 29 mp5 respectively for the abovementioned 2 trinkets. Of course over different talent builds, classes and cast rotations, your mileage my vary.

Comment by ArgentSun

Nobody spoke from Paladin's perspective... Usually, if there are 2 holy paladins in 10 man raids, most of the time we can pull the heals off by just spamming our Flash of Light and keeping the mana at 90%+, so the trinket isn't really that much of a fuss. But on boss fights, I would love to get the thing - usually I cast 4-5 FoLs for 1 HL, so I spend most of my time interrupting my mana coming every 5 seconds. This trinket will be lovely as soon as I get the Ace...

Comment by 127122

I just got it proc off of a Consume Magic. So it doesn't matter whether or not the spell actually uses mana.

Comment by 35804

I have been farming this Beast now for about 4 months with 4 to 6 runs every weekend. We ran this with three level 70s. Over the course of 30 kills give or take 5, we got 7 Finkle's Skinner. Wowheads % drop is way off or I just have horrible luck. We also managed to pull out Alcor's Sunrazor, Felstriker, Skullflame Shield, Cloudkeeper Legplates in the course of those 4 months. The runecloth and Large Brilliant Shards made us a ton of money, more so then dailys.

I ended up getting better priest trinkets and gave this to my wife (restoration druid). Now on to farm the Bangle of Endless Blessings.

Hokuto

The 2.4 changes towards the regen from spirit, it's still not worth using that trinket over other options, like Tome of Diabolic Remedy or Fel Reaver Piston.

I disagree with this statement, your talking about 25 man raids where a priest or druid can get this pretty easily. You can't start at the top :P

Comment by 88930

Is it me or this blue dragon is really having more proc after 2.4.2?

Today my card proc 3 times when fighting Kaz'rogal which is a 2 minutes fight

Before the patch
if i have 2 procs in this fight i will be a very happy priest
so do you guys have some strange proc rate after 2.4.2?

Feel free to rate down if i am wrong lol

Comment by Novawolf

<nerd logic>I betcha anything this is a spoof of the commonly known Yu-Gi-Oh card, the "Blue-Eyes White Dragon"</nerd logic>

Comment by 182004

I use this with my Tome of Diabolic Remedy and seldom ever run low on mana. It has a great proc rate, and often find myself seeing it proc multiple times as I spam CoH and renew on the raid. A definite must have before WOTLK, as level 80 druids/priests will have a lot, lot more spirit.

Comment by najani

Just checked a wws report of the night. It is procing, but I swear the icon isn't appearing. Maybe I'm just blind :-/

Comment by 92698

I would say if you have over 500 spirit fully raid buffed, the bangle isn't going to add anything to your innervate because the amount of spirit you have will top off your entire mana bar from 1-2K to full on its own, without Bangle. So wearing Bangle would just be a wasted trinket slot in cases like that.

Im not a theorycrafter so ive never actually done the math for this, but until I see the math I'd have to completely disagree with this.

Tree druid I raid/clear Sunwell - Raid buffed I have probably about 7-800 spirit and while using this trinket with innervate would be a complete waste it is never off CD. I'll call that im stopping healing for about 10 seconds so the other healers know the raid will be lacking some hots... pop bangle and sit for about 5 seconds and get a really good mini-innervate from this - Every 2 minutes. Sometimes I'll pair it up with my essence of the martyr giving me a +healing +spirit buff on my hots when the raid is taking heavy aoe damage.

I have DM:BD as well sitting in my bank but the use on bangle just seems so much better to me. Any theorycrafters feel like going through the numbers of mana you would get back popping bangle every 2min outside the 5sr?

Comment by Erethzium

I think people are confused over the proc rate, lol.

2% does not mean 2 / 100 casts will make it proc.

2% means, well, as if you rolled a 100-sided die (yes they exist) each time you cast, and if it lands on 1 or 2 it procs.

Comment by dushkin

I just tested this trinket on my druid. Unbuffed, my regeneration is 678/251 mp5 while resting and casting respectively.

I used a macro to count how many times I cast lifebloom, cast it for several mana cycles, innervated, drank a bit, and get the following results:

370 casts of lifebloom yielded 8 procs of this trinket.

Crunching some numbers:
Proc chance: (8/370)*100 = 2.16

Mana gained in 15 seconds while casting/not casting:
753 (casting)
2034 (not casting)

Difference in mana gain: 1281 mana (4.8 lifeblooms @ 70)

100 Lifeblooms = 26400 mana
Also grant ~30 seconds of mana regen at 100% rate
Refunds about 2562 mana for every 100 LB casts
100 LB casts, approx. with trinket: 23838 mana
That's the cost of about 90.29 casts.
238 mana each instead of 264, 26 mp cheaper

In theory, should this trinket proc, while I'm unbuffed
it will "cheapen" LB by around 26 mp.

These are calculations I did for myself, with my gear. I like this trinket.

What I have proved with this is the following. First of all, the proc rate really is as advertised and does not appear to be modified for level 70 characters. Secondly, it really does make a difference. It may not appear as much, but this trinket is great for mana regeneration. Being obtainable without any need to access high end raid content is a plus. It took me from Karazhan to Kil'jaeden and I still will use it in wrath (which comes out tomorrow night). Lovely trinket, I recommend it for restoration druids.

Comment by 56783

As a priest with a holy/discipline hybrid spec stacking spirit, i have recently grabbed this trinket out of my bank, and tested it together with the new Darkmoon Card: Greatness (spirit version).

Amazing results ensued. Given the 33% uptime of the 300 spirit proc of the other card, you are bound to get uptimes of both trinkets together, resulting in massive regen. And that's without having to worry about the timing of the procs yourself.

Comment by sinaraine

does anyone know if this has chance to proc on ever single pennace or only the initial cast?

Comment by 295969

Ok- as I've seen much debate on forums on which trinket to use in combination with Darkmoon card: Blue Dragon I will put in my two cents here:

The debate is over Darkmoon Card: Greatness (+90 spir) and Darkmoon Card: Greatness (+90 int).

The answer, regardless of class, is the same: Darkmoon Card: Greatness.

If you are using both trinkets in combination, the +90 spirit from Darkmoon Card: Greatness will make the Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon much more effective. Although intellect does slightly increase your mana regeneration rate, the primary thing that it does is to raise the size of your mana pool. Spirit, however, has much more of an effect on mana regeneration.

Don't get me wrong- Darkmoon Card: Greatness has it's place, but it isn't here. The whole reason people use Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon is for mana regen specs; thus, Darkmoon Card: Greatness wins the day.

Comment by 122266

I have this trinket equiped on my 80 spirit-build priest. With 1200 spirit raid-buffed, each proc tics three times at 1100 MP5, so for each proc 3300 mana. I cast about 100-200 time in a 5 minute fight depending on debuff duty, so let's assume 150 casts. With a 2% proc rate that is 3 procs over the span of five minutes. (This is a conservative estimation).

3 (procs) x 3300 (mana per proc) = 9900 mana total
5 minutes = 300 seconds

300 seconds / 5 = 60 mp5 TICS

9900 divided by the 60 mp5 TICS = 165

or in other words, THIS TRINKET is THE SAME AS A TRINKET THAT SAYS "Equip- 165 mp5"
and better yet, it will ETERNALLY and forever scale with your gear! It can only get better!

In other words, this is easily the most OP tinket for spirit builds in the game. Even unbuffed it is still 115 mp5. Of course that is only if it procs, but it seems to proc a lot more then 2%... anyways, I'm glad my guild helped me farm this back in MC days as I walk around with the most SECRET, OP trinket in the game!

Comment by Flyv

Yes, definitely procs regularly for level 80s. Also seems to have no cooldown: my combat log from a Naxx/10 run shows it proccing twice in as little as two seconds.

Comment by Mymloch

I am using this as a Resto Druid to run all end-game content in the game of this date. The math above is nice to look at, but simply put, this card procs at least once every other fight for me, and sometimes multiple times in one encounter.

Comment by 313622

I'm glad to read some of the glowing reports about this trinket. I picked up all the beast cards from AH for about 100g, bar the Ace, which I farmed from The Beast in UBRS. The Faire starts on Monday :)
I don't have the time or the gold to get my hands on the greatness card, but Spirit-World Glass dropped for me last night and I'm really looking forward to having both equipped (at least for a boss set). I like the idea of activating Glass when Dragon procs, but will probably spam Glass as and when it's available.
As they both lack SP and Haste I'm wondering about their usefullness during most trash pulls, where mana regen is rarely an issue.

Comment by Spleener

It is the end of an era.

Announced by Blizzard today:

# Regeneration while not casting (outside of the “five second rule”) will be decreased. We think that (1) the ability to cast heal over time spells and then sit back and (2) benefitting from a clearcasting proc that also gets you out of the five second rule both provide too much mana regeneration, even over short time periods.

# To make this change, we are reducing mana regeneration granted by Spirit across the board. However we are also boosting the effects of talents such as Meditation that increase regeneration while casting. The net result should be that your regeneration while casting will stay about the same, but your not-casting regeneration will be reduced. This change will have little impact on dps casters, since they are basically always casting.

Which means that this level 60 trinket will no longer be best-in-slot for regen at 80. It'll be sad to put this thing into retirement after about two years of using it, but I suppose it's for the best.

Comment by Kriyet

Don't ditch your dragon yet. Today, Ghostcrawler amended the original statement about the mana regen being a Spirit nerf:

"– The amount of base mana regen granted has been reduced 40%. We called this “Spirit” in the notes, since most players associate OOFSR regen with Spirit, but in reality Int factors into the equation as well and we only lowered the constant, not the relative contributions of Int or Spirit. In retrospect, this probably caused more confusion than it alleviated, but mana regeneration is a fairly technical concept.
– The effects of talents that provide mana regen while casting have been increased by 67%. This includes: Arcane Meditation, Improved Spirit Tap, Intensity, Mage Armor, Meditation, Pyromaniac, and Spirit Tap. For example, Intensity and Meditation are now 17/33/50% mana regen while casting (up from 10/20/30%). For most dps classes who never got much mana from OOFSR in the first place, the results should not be noticeable. Boomkin may be a possible exception because of Innervate, and we’ll take a look at that.
– This should leave mana regeneration while casting (even the contribution of Spirit) relatively unchanged, but reduce mana regeneration while not casting by 40%."

So, they will not be nerfing Spirit specifically in the next patch, but nerfing overall mana regen OOC. Which means in-combat, I expect my Blue Dragon to stay great. And, like some other posters, I can report that at level 80 this is proccing constantly, at least once a fight. Not unusual to end a night's raiding with 35-40 proccs in the WWS log.

Comment by 127303

Unless it is changed to a higher percent, this is getting nerfed to the ground in 3.1, as OOC mana regen, upon which this trinket depends, is being significantly lowered.

R.I.P.

Comment by Kalx

If you're trying to sell this on your server, be very specific about what this trinket can do, it's very hard to convince people that a level 60 trinket is still good at 80.

Comment by 335661

I use this trinket on my 80 holy priest in combination with https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=39388. It's the same concept from above with the DC:Greatness (spirit version) but with 2 added advantages:

1) You don't have to worry about getting lucky on the uptimes of both procs. Given that the DC:G has about a 30 to 35% uptime and the DC:BD has approximately 15% uptime (varies depending on play style), it's not likely that they will be active at the same time very often.

2) Spirit-World Glass is free assuming you're farming Naxx-10 weekly, and DC:G decks are still going for an obscene amount on most servers.

I am not exactly certain how much the upcoming 3.1.0 patch is going to nerf O5SR regen, but currently by timing the spirit use on my other trinket with the <Aura of the Blue Dragon> proc, I net about a 4k to 6k mana return each time (I roll with about 1200-1300 spirit raid buffed).

Definitely recommended at level 80 for holy priests and resto druids during endurance fights. I still roll with spellpower and haste trinkets for trash and short fights.

Comment by 32144

In patch 3.1 mana regen from spirit it being reduced, which in tern will make this trinkets noticeably less effective.

Comment by 341967

With the upcoming changes to spirit regeneration is 3.1 (e.g. Meditation and Intensity going up to 50% of out-of-5second rule casting and the amount of non-casting regen being reduced to accommodate this for total regen being approximately the same) this trinket falls significantly in usefulness.

For example, if you had 1000 mp5 while not casting before, and Meditation was 30% of that so 300mp5 while casting... post 3.1 you will still have ~300mp5 while casting with Meditation providing 50% of your normal regen instead of 30%, so your non-casting regen will be floating somewhere around 600mp5. Approximately a 40% reduction in regen given per-proc by this trinket, based off the suggestions of blue posts on the topic of 5second rule...

Comment by 346382

I think this is getting severely nerfed due to the ooc regen changes in 3.1. Can anyone confirm?

Comment by 257386

As of a recent patch, out-of-combat mana regen from spirit has been drastically reduced. The difference between combat mana regen and out-of-combat mana regen is much lower. As a result, this item is much weaker, and is no longer the best mana regen trinket in the game. Soul of the Dead is now better, as I'm sure are a number of other items.

For some example numbers: this item gives me an extra 200mp5 for 15 seconds, for a total of 600 mana, as a priest in Naxx and heroic gear at level 80.

Comparatively, Soul of the Dead will proc at an equal rate if you have 8% spell crit chance, and more often if your crit is higher (which it probably is). For me, Soul of the Dead gives 50% more MP when it procs than Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon does. Plus it gives extra crit rating, which is very nice.

Je'tze's Bell on the other hand is still worse mana regen (about half as good for me), and procs exactly as often as this card, but has 106 spellpower. Since I have one set of equipment for spellpower and a second set for mana regen, I would probably not use the bell unless I didn't have any better spellpower trinkets than it.

Comment by 45199

I'm not sure I understand your math. SotD returns 900 mana per proc, but has a 45s internal CD. Any Priest in decent gear is looking at 850/500 regen raid-buffed, so you're looking at a 20s proc of Blue Dragon returning 1400 mana. However, BD has no internal CD (procs will even overlap at times). I had it proc 4 times on Emalon tonight, 3 of those in a 90s period. Pop Spirit World and you can forget about SotD, or any other trinket, even coming close in terms of pure regen.

Comment by 197345

I'm seeing a ton of posts saying something along the lines of "Oh wow, it gives back more mana than <X lvl80 trinket>," while forgetting that said trinket also has a substantial boost to spell power or the like. There are only two pure regen trinkets at 80:

Spark of Hope - https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=45703
and Spirit World Glass - https://www.wowhead.com/cata/item=39388

Comparing DC:BD to cards like Illusion is comparing apples and oranges. To compare it to the two other regen trinkets:

Spark of Hope's proc is 140 mp5 if you're casting an average of 1.5 sec (or instant) spells. At 3 sec spells it's half that, 70 mp5, and if you have haste with your 1.5/instant spam (i.e., disc priest), it's more. 100 spirit is on top of that.

Spirit World Glass is very situational, but consider that many fights have a break where you don't need to be casting right then. Off the top of my head in Ulduar, there are breaks on Razorscale (right after she lifts off), XT (heart phase), Iron Council if no one's taking Brundir's lightning squid, Hodir while running to ice floes, Freya between add waves if tank healing is covered, and all of Mimiron's phase transitions. In these cases, you're getting the full or partial benefit from the +336 spirit while not casting at all, negating the advantage of stacking SWG with this trinket.

Now, assuming 600 base regen while not casting as a ballpark figure, let's see how much BD gives back. Assuming no ICD and an average cast time of 2 seconds, you'll see a proc on average every 100 seconds. Any class that has enough spirit for this trinket to matter also has a 50% mana regen while casting talent, so you're gaining 300 mana/5 while casting over what you'd normally have. You get 3 of those 5 second intervals, for a gain of 900 mana every 50 seconds, which is 18 mana per second or 90 mp5.

So comparing: Spark of Hope is very clearly superior even before the spirit at any cast time (faster casts proc BD more, and also benefit more from spark of hope). The benefit of Spirit World Glass is harder to quantify, but assuming 1000 spirit and int (reasonable in Ulduar gear), you have a base spirit-based regen of 529 when not casting (and, presumably, half that while casting). The passive spirit effect on SWG will raise this by 44 while not casting, 22 while casting. The use effect will add an additional 172 mp5 while not casting, or 86 while casting. Assuming instant clicking of the trinket and constant casting, that's 344 per usage every 2 min or 14 mp5 for a total of 58 mp5 for the whole trinket. Assuming it's used intelligently, but adding an extra thirty seconds between uses to account for that, it's a gain of 23 mp5 from the use, or a total of 67 from the entire SWG.

TL;DR: DC:BG is strictly inferior to the Spark of Hope by a considerable margin at all cast time averages. It is superior to Spirit-World Glass in all cases, also by a large margin .

Comment by 367686

question.. would this trinket be viable for all healers/spellcasters or just those that utilize spirit?

seems like most of the replys are from those such users.. i am a resto shaman and would find this mana regen quite interesting if it procs as such....

edit upon further investigation i found out that it procs most when you cast many short fast casts... which paladin and shamans dont tend to do as much.... such a shame because this trinket could be had for such a great price and it seems to work wonders....

or even quite possibly i can start casting cheap and frequent instants which could cause me to proc this item for mana refil?

Comment by 125795

486mp5 while not casting
253mp5 while casting

"2% chance on successful spellcast to allow 100% of your Mana regeneration to continue while casting for 15 sec."

In other words, you get same mp5 as if not casting when this procs.
For me, that is 486mp5-253mp5=233mp5 for 15secs when it procs

So, 233mp5 for 15sec = 233x3=699mana when it procs

So..how often does it proc? as a drood with Gift of the Earthmother, and the soft cap for hasterating achieved, my GCD is 1sec.
2% proc chance per cast, means I have to cast 50times with 1sec. It will proc every 50sec.

So.. this trinket will give me 699mana every 50sec, thats ~70mp5 on average while casting.

I explained my math like this, so any druid can do it themselves.

So, to sum some druid mp5 trinkets up:
Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon
~70mp5(with my gear)

Spark of Hope
20.5spellpower
249.4mp5

Spirit-World Glass
28.75spellpower
55.1mp5

Energy Siphon
68spellpower
54mp5

... so its better then naxx mp5 trinkets, but worse then ulduar mp5 trinkets.

MP5 trinkets for druids(sorted by mp5 ofc):
250mp5 Spark of Hope +20.5 spellpower
80mp5 Soul Preserver +75 spellpower
75mp5 Darkmoon Card: Greatness +39 spellpower
72mp5 Figurine - Sapphire Owl
70mp5 Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon
70mp5 Majestic Dragon Figurine +37spellpower
69mp5 Living Ice Crystals
67mp5 Tears of the Vanquished
66mp5 Show of Faith +140 spellpower
60mp5 Spark of Life +73 haste rating
57mp5 Binding Light +68 spellpower
55mp5 Spirit-World Glass +29 spellpower
54mp5 Energy Siphon +68 spellpower
53mp5 Sif's Remembrance +110spellpower
39mp5 Valonforth's Remembrance +10 spellpower
36mp5 Winged Talisman +58 spellpower
34mp5 Je'Tze's Bell +106 spellpower
33mp5 Soul of the Dead +2% crit
32mp5 Talisman of Resurgence +100 spellpower
29mp5 Talisman of Troll Divinity +15 spellpower
28mp5 Cannoneer's Morale +47 spellpower
27mp5 Pandora's Plea +136 spellpower
26mp5 Memento of Tyrande +62 spellpower
25mp5 Darkmoon Card: Illusion +100 spellpower
21mp5 Bangle of Endless Blessings +5 spellpower
20mp5 Forethought Talisman +111 spellpower
12mp5 Futuresight Rune +68 spellpower

Comment by 504602

maybe its nothing but for some reason i thought of "Blue Eyes White Dragon." Yu-gi-oh reference perhaps?

Disclosure: i dont play yu-gay-hoe, nor do i condone the malicious act of playing said game. I can not be held responsible for any loss of relationships, reputation, friends, or family members resulting in the playing of this..."Game".

Thank you have a nice day.

Comment by 517342

With all this talk about this trinket great for healers, what about mages? I was wondering cause its available in the AH and just wanted to research before I investing in it.

Comment by Aleq

Just bought this on my holypriest, for offspecc.
Got around 1050 mana while not casting.

Gonna try it out and see how it works, i replaced it with normal:Sliver of pure ice.
I prio spamming over quality heals.

Comment by 359370

Any thoughts as to how this will be affected by the new mechanics in Cata? I've got 5 of the 8 cards in my bank and am wondering if it might be a good idea to have this trinket on hand...

Comment by Roggy

i do have a question but is tis trinket any good to a shammy healer ?

Comment by 45199

Officially worthless. Has no affect whatsoever on proc, since there is only one kind of regeneration now.

Comment by 704257

"I am the Blue Dragon: Magic, wisdom, power. Know them, wield them, for they are the tools of the wise and the brave."

The Blue Dragon symbolises power, and how you use it. Without restrictions and self-control, power corrupts and taints.

Power, knowledge and intuition infuse this card in the upright position.
Corruption, tirany and madness infuse this card in the reversed position.

Comment by birkett83

I've been trying to work out if this is viable as a pre-raid healer mana regen trinket at lvl 85. To get the best out of the blue dragon proc, I will consider pairing it with . This has 245 intellect and gives 1425 spirit on use. To isolate the value of the blue dragon card, I will compute the mana regen for the two trinkets as a pair and then subtract the mana regen for the figurine on its own.

Some assumptions:

Average time between casts is 2.5 seconds, meaning the proc occurs once every 125 seconds on average.
Healer is in Pre-Raid gear, with 4080 Int and 2800 spirit with the dream owl and blue dragon trinkets equipped. I computed these numbers by adding up int and spirit on blue level 85 items (mostly the ones from justice point vendor), suitable enchants and buffs (e.g. flask and food buff). anyone with access to the beta, please tell me if these numbers are wildly inaccurate.

Using the formula from elitist jerks, Mp5=(0.001+spirit*sqrt(int)*0.003345)*5 this gives 2991 MP5 regen from spirit out of combat, or 1495 mana regen from spirit in combat. This is ignoring other sources of mana regen. (Don't forget you get 5% of max mana every 5 seconds even if you have no regen from spirit, which will affect the amount shown in your character screen but that doesn't affect our calculations here. You can see the mana from spirit by hovering your mouse over the spirit stat in your character screen).

Every 125 seconds (on average) the blue dragon procs. Suppose we immediately use the figurine. Then our spirit increases to 4225, and our mana regen from spirit increases to 4513 for 15 seconds (while both the darkmoon card and figurine are active). The figurine buff lasts 20 seconds, so we have an additional 5 seconds at 2256 mana regen from spirit. This gives (4513-1495)*15/5+(2256-1495) = 9851 mana every 125 seconds, or 392 mana per 5 seconds.

In contrast, if we had only the figurine and not the blue dragon, we could get (2256-1495)*20/5 = 3044 mana every 120 seconds, which is 127 mp5.

TL;DR version, The blue dragon is worth 392-127 = 265 mp5 at level 85 when paired with the figurine - dream owl.

Comment by zagi

Ok, a sick theory - just throwing it out there:

This trinket procs, you instantly throw down a Mana Tide Totem (350% spirit for 15sec), and activate your other trinket Core of Ripeness. How much of your mana pool could you potentially regenerate? Remember that the spirit trinket probably adds like 9000 spirit at the time of activation.

Comment by 749445

Tried it out and casted till Blue Dragon procced. Then I quickly dropped Mana Tide Totem and I went from 2900 cmp5 to 12515 cmp5.

screenshot

Next test - To see how high I can get with mana regen (with or without proccing Blue Dragon).
So I kept casting to have my Heartsong and my Blood of Isiset 333 proc, giving 200+ and 1512+ spirit. Then quickly pop Mana Tide Totem and screenshot.
Resulting in a 20853 Mana Regen (not in combat though, cause Blue Dragon didn't proc at that time, but from the previous test I concluded that Blue Dragon does work to match CMP5 to MP5)

screenshot

So now for the ultimate test - have both trinkets proc + Heartsong and have Mana Tide up
After a couple of tries with buffs just running out before I could screenshot I did manage to get one with: and Heartsong, and Blessing of Isiset, and Blue Dragon, and Mana Tide up

screenshot

What more proof do you need?

Comment by Drarion

Would this trinket still be good in Cata? its going for 15k on my server.

Comment by bk3nj

Interesting theorycrafting going on about this trinket's viability at 85. Given Blizzard's stance on wanting people to keep upgrading their gear, however, I can't really see them continuing to allow the continued viability of a level 60 trinket in current endgame.

I'd strongly advise against overpaying for this trinket - the party won't last forever.

Comment by 257386

Yeah, they don't normally like to let old stuff stay as viable as this is. This trinket was arguably the best mana regen trinket through all of Burning Crusade and semi-viable through a lot of Wrath though, simply because they forgot about it.

It hasn't been changed in the last 3 years so I doubt it's going to suddenly get changed now. It's always possible of course, but it was way more likely in Burning Crusade and didn't happen then. And it's not that expensive now.

Comment by 271277

I tried this thing out on our 10man raid through Bastion of Twilight and Blackwing Descent. As a paladin healer, i had multiple instant casts and enough haste to cast divine lights in under 2 sec, so I really wanted this thing to work. One important fact is that this trinket CAN proc from Word of Glory, even though it is a manaless cast.

In general I had a good time keeping up the buff - i would say I average'd to 1 PPM. During the twin dragon fight in Bastion, I saw it proc twice in the span of 20 sec - it fell off, then a few seconds later it procced again. I can definitely say this thing has no internal cooldown, just a very small chance to proc itself.

My spirit, while fully buffed and healing is about 3808. This translates to 5503 mp5 out of combat and 3500 in combat. Whenever the trinket procced, my incombat matched my OOC - the 5503 mark.

I cannot definitely say whether this trinket is better or worse then any other I have. Currently, I have a Jar of Ancient Remedies as my only 359 healing trinket ( i cannot afford the tsunami card). I think I will use this blue dragon card until I can get the one off Cho'gall - I firmly believe it outperforms the Blood of Isistet in terms of mana regen, which is currently my highest priority.

Comment by 54884

Anyone done any testing 4.0+ on this card? With the change of combat regen?

Comment by 203736

This was extremely powerful prior to 4.0.6, at least for Resto Shaman, because dropping mana tide during a proc results in much higher mana gains, and it had a chance to proc on each tick of puddle-type healing spells like Healing Rain (not one chance per target, one chance per wave of ticks), although it was impossible to tell if the proc was a result of the ticks, or a result of an Earthliving proc. It appears this may have been stealth-nerfed in 4.0.6. Post 4.0.6, it now appears that it ONLY procs on initial active spellcasts (i.e., no more procs on passive "casts" like Earthliving). The mana tide gains are still enormous, especially with high spirit, but the proc rate seems much, much lower for shaman. Healers with a lot of instant casts, like druids, may still find good use for it.

Also, currently virtually worthless for Holy Priests, because their in-combat mana regen is already 80%. An extra 20% for about 20% of the time is not worth a trinket slot.

EDIT: For people who want specific numbers, my resto shaman's unbuffed combat regen is 2714, and OOCR is 4259. For each proc of this trinket, that's 4635 mana. At about 1PPM, that's 386 mp5, which isn't amazing, but it's not terrible. However, under mana tide, my shaman's OOCR is 16612, and in-combat is 8891. That means that over the course of a mana tide, this trinket will optimally return an EXTRA 23k mana over what mana tide would normally give. If you use mana tide every 3.5 minutes or so during a long fight, that's 547mp5 from the mana tides alone. To sum up - for a resto shaman, this trinket can potentially deliver over 775mp5 in long fights. As gear improves through Cataclysm, these numbers will go up. Of course, the risk is that it won't proc, and you will get no benefit whatsoever. With the suspected stealth nerf I mention above, this bad outcome is far more likely, making this trinket very risky to use, considering that better and better regen trinkets will continue to drop.

On the positive side, I see these on the AH all the time for about 100G, so it is a cheap way to get a passable regen trinket. Perhaps a by-product of folks leveling inscription?

Comment by 882789

Still using this at 79, one could argue that I should have replaced it but it's still proccing so I still love it

Comment by Thottbot

Scenerio: 5 minute fight. Assume 50% within the 5-second rule, and 348 spirit.

Mindtap Talisman restores 660 mana in 5 minutes.

Blue Dragon procs an average of once each boss fight (50 casts of Flash Heal * 2% proc chance). 50 FH = 19k mana used, a high but attainable number. If it does proc, 700 mana is restored. (100 mana/tick * 7 ticks). However, if it procs during a period where you aren't going to be within the FSR already, then the proc is a waste.

So, you can get Mindtap Talisman, a blue and easily attainable in a 5-man run of DM west, or you can spend alot of time instancing random mobs and spending money on the last few cards you need to collect to create an item that does the same thing in a less predictable manner.

Yeah.

If the trinket was activateable with a 5-minute cooldown, then at least it could be counted on for fights less than 5 minutes long, in periods you know you would be casting (so you can take full advantage of being within the five second rule). In that case, it would clearly be better than Mindtap Talisman and worth it's epic status. As it exists now, it's a pile of crap for being epic.

Priests with 5/5 Meditation reduce the effectiveness of the Blue Dragon trinket as they are always regenning 15% of their mana. With 3 pieces of Transcendence, it's 30% regeneration which further makes the Blue Dragon trinket less attractive. Same goes for mages with Mage Armor and Arcane Meditiation. Therefore, to even compete with Mintap Talisman or Shard of the Scale, this trinket needs to add +100% mana regeneration instead of giving a flat 100% mana regeneration.

I'm willing to put money on the procbuff being dispellable too, further reducing this trinket's usefulness in fights like Garr and PvP -- any situation where buffs can be dispelled.

Comment by Thottbot

It depends on the situation. First off it's entirely spirit-dependent. If you get more than 100 mana regen per tick from spirit then this trinket could be considered epic for you. For fights where I do a lot of dispels this is likely to proc more than once every 5 minutes. Including dispels I easily do more than 50 spells every 5 minutes vs. say, Baron Geddon.

Furthermore, atm it procs on everything that could be considered a "spell" including wands and creating items. For a non shadowpriest that makes it a powerful item for soloing.

Comment by Thottbot

Let's review the basics.

1-Spirit gives you mana back if you haven't cast any spells in a while. You gain somewhere between 30 and say 200 mana every tick from your spirit.

2- When you are in combat (or literally, casting things), the Five Second Rule kicks in and you stop gaining mana. Your mana regeneration rate drops to zero when the Five Second Rule is on you. You can't see this "debuff" but it's part of the game rules- you just don't gain any mana for five seconds after you cast anything. You're at zero mana? Tough. You have to stop casting for 5 seconds and then your spirit starts trickling in more.

3- What this card does is lets you override the Five Second Rule when it procs. Instead of your mana regen from spirit rate dropping to zero for 5 seconds after you cast, it stays at 100%, casting or not. This card turns off the Five Second Rule and lets you keep casting while also gaining precious mana.

So what does it mean? It means that in long, drawn out boss fights, you can keep casting and casting, and when it procs, your spirit will keep filling up your mana even while you fight and heal.

This is perfect for druids, priests, paladins and shamans casting lots of small heals in a row in big boss fights. Take Firemaw for example. Ordinarily the fight is maybe 10 minutes long, and you have to keep casting all the time to heal everyone. Firemaw tries to melt the face off of everyone he can see, so you have to constantly spam heals the entire fight. Someone pinned down by the five second rule would never regain any mana until their mana was out and they couldn't heal anymore. Then they wait five seconds. Then they slowly start gaining mana. Someone with this card spamming heals is going to proc the card a couple of times in ten minutes, and when they do, they start gaining mana from their spirit, ignoring the 5second rule. How much mana does your spirit restore if you were out of combat in 15 seconds? 200? 400? Maybe even 800 if your spirit is really high. In a long boss battle, every time this procs, it gently adds another 400-800 mana to your pool. How many other trinkets can keep doing that with no cooldown? This card is like a Second Wind that never stops.

Comment by Thottbot

I was led to believe that Blue Dragon procs on wands and even a TICK of a renew, but this is FALSE. It does, however, proc on in the initial cast of a renew, as well as other instants such as shield, inner fire, fortitude, etc.

Comment by Thottbot

Okay,

Here comes the maths:

- When spamming spells you have a fairly constant probability of this trinket being up. The probability is: 1-(98%)^(15/spell speed)

- This is the probability that one of your spells in the last 15 seconds would have tringered the trinket.

- this means that spamming a 1.5 spell gives you a 18% chance of having this trinket up at any given moment.

- With a spirit of 300, you should have an OOC regen of about 188 mana/5 sec. Therefore, you will effectively gain 18% * 188 = about 34mana/5secs while spamming a 1.5 spell.

- Priests need to remember to remove 15% from any of these figures if they have meditation.

- When spamming 2.5 spells this goes down to 22mana/5sec, while when spamming instant spells this goes up to 49mana/5secs

- therefore, as long as you have a high spirit and plan on spamming spells in end-game content, this trinket is excellent!

Comment by Thottbot

I know Shamans have less Spirit, but the Card can be proc by setting totems right after 1.10 and its nice in Combo with 'Lesser Healing Wave'.
Get it if ur Shaman is a Healbot in Raids or if you are Elemental specced its nice for farming.

Comment by Thottbot

okay,
there is a lot of debte as to the usefulness of this trinket.

I will make the assumption that your are spamming spells with around a 1.5s casting time as this is what I usually do on my paladin - either cleansing or FoL healing.

At any one point in time we need to know the probability of the trinket being up. We do this by working out the probability that the trinket did not fire in the last 15 secinds, then 1- that number is or probabiliy.

If you cast 10 spells at 1.5s per cast in the last 15 seconds, the probability of the trinket not being up is 0.98 * 0.98 * ... * 0.98 or 0.98 to the power of 10 = 0.817. Therefore the probability of the trinket being up is 0.183.

Spirit regen with 250 Spi is 13 + (Spi / 4), or 75.5 mana / 2s or 188.75 mana / 5s.

Therefore, on average you will be regenning 188.75 * 0.183 = 34.52 mana / 5s

This is much more than mindtap or even double the onyxia trinket (that I almost fell into the trap of bidding DKP on the other day - thank you maths!). That is only looking at my raid buffed Spi which is usually between 250 and 300 - imagine this on a fully spi buffed priest and you will realise the power...

Comment by Thottbot

install MUSE addon, check out boss fights when you in five-second-rule most of the time, and equip this deck in this encounters
also it pwns in dispell fights, when you need to dispell magic, abolish disease or spam heal spells most of the fight time

Comment by Thottbot

If you're a priest, and have a high amount of spirit (300+), and you raid.. you'll love it.

Comment by Thottbot

patch 1.11.0 bug fixes:
"Items which allow mana regeneration while casting will not stack greater than 100%."
"Fixed a bug where characters were able to exceed 100% of their normal mana regeneration while casting."

Comment by Thottbot

TalShuler's math is correct about the 18.3% average regen with 1.5s casting, but with one addition. At the begining of a fight, boss or otherwise, the chance that the proc fired in the last 15 seconds is zero. You can discount this over the long run, but 10 casts is significant for short fights.

On first cast, the chance is 1-(0.98^1)=2%. On second cast, 1-(0.98^2)=4%. And so on...
Cast % Active Average Regen
1st 2.0% 2.0%
2 4.0% 3.0%
3 5.9% 3.9%
4 7.8% 4.9%
5 9.6% 5.8%
6 11.1% 6.8%
7 13.2% 7.7%
8 14.9% 8.6%
9 16.7% 9.5%
10 18.3% 10.4%
11 18.3% 11.1%
12 18.3% 11.7%

This means that after 10 casts, you're averaging 10.4% regen over the entire fight (averaged 1-10). (The rest of this is specific to me, a shaman with 224 unbuffed spirit and 6600 mana). The most I estimate I can keep up is around 18 consecutive casts... gives 13.9% average regen. With my spirit, that puts me at 21.5 average MP5.

But, if you have to pause due to fear, changing targets, etc. your % regen rate decreases to 2% within 15 seconds.

For me to beat Mindtap, I have to cast 7 consecutive casts. Shard of the Scale takes 10 consecutive casts.

Comment by Thottbot

Resto Druids

Get this trinket if you like the idea of getting a free 1500 mana back WHILE CASTING IN COMBAT.

If your a Tree of Life druid, and are casting Hots constantly, this will proc for you, alot. I've had it since my mc days, and this trinket only gets better with higher spirit. It can and has proc'd twice in a row, and if your constantly casting through a fight, use this for that fight. Plus, if it procs alot during a fight, you can save your innervates for a holy priest / pally that prolly has more + healing and higher spirit than you anyway, making you more effective for your guild / raid. Main healing priest / pally will love you and remeber you if you keep their mana pool up, hence, you'll prolly get more invites to good raids.

Happy Hunting Leaf Brains

Comment by Thottbot

2%= good proc rate

The spell caster deck hands down

Comment by Allakhazam

This trinket is amazing for a priest. take a moment to think of what constitutes a 'successfull spellcasting'. Instants: renew, shield, sw:p, Inner fire... You could hit inner fire rank 1 enough times to trigger the effect... Yes, flash heal is great too, but the insta's are this trinkets key to efficiency. Use em :O

I will be putting this trinket in high priority, its usefullness is severly underrated!

Jotun
Priest of Skullcrusher

Comment by Allakhazam

any idea which deck of cards for this trinket?
and what are the other reward ?
thx

Comment by Allakhazam

For the priest vs mage debate.

Your mage runs oom, you can wand for decent dps while you regen.
Your priest runs oom, prepare to die.

Priest>Mage (I have both 60 mage & priest)

And for the record this whole debate is retarded, as anyone can collect these cards as they're non binding.

Comment by Allakhazam

Goes off 1 in 50 spells? Forget that... and forget casting inner fire rank 1 repeatably until it goes off =)

If you were to cast a spell on every single global cooldown, it would still take 50 seconds before it goes off =/

Sure it'd be ok to have, but barely worth 100g -.-

Comment by Allakhazam

Why not get the Mindtap Talisman AND this card? wow, that was a tough one.

Comment by Allakhazam

I heard it was ''Beasts'' but I'm not sure

Comment by Allakhazam

One thing you have to realize is this. As a mage, single cast spells like frostbolt or fireball only cast once and take mana on succesfull cast (end of channeling.) Spells like blizzard and arcane missles have multiple chances of finishing a cast, as they are doing multiple points of damage. I remember reading blizzard alone has 4-5 chances of proc'ing something.

Best way to look at it is with Clearcasting. (10% chance of proc for your next spell to have mana cost reduced by 100%) Sometimes it will happen right away with AM or Blizz, other times mid channeling.

If same holds true, great item IMO. If any of my thoughts here are not correct, by all means please correct.

Comment by Allakhazam

its only use is in a pve enviroment during a boss encounter.

It requires 8 rare cards, which drop off mobs throughout the world... who would've imagined they'd design it with PVE in mind! Go figure.

Comment by Allakhazam

i'm a frost mage on eu-aman'thul and the only mage to have it, as far as i know.
in a mc or ubrs runs this thing procs endlessly! it seems much more than 2% to me, and it also procs while fishing, blinking and making water, which is very funny ^^
if it procs and i am casting frostbolts, i have the same amount of mana after the 15 seconds end as i had before. if a clearcast procs within that time, i even have more mana than before. can there be anything more usefull than that ?

Edited, Sun Sep 11 11:37:13 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

got it on my druid, nice :D

Edited, Nov 11th 2006 at 10:32pm PST by laminatorq

Comment by Allakhazam

Why is this the beast deck? i was assembling the cards for my druid, thinking it would be some cool combat trinket, and it is for casting! omg!

Comment by Allakhazam

its actually 70% more mana reg compared to mage armor with 2% chance and for 15 sec.
on an average 60 mana/ sec reg tic its like:

0.7 * 15sec * 60 mana/s = 630 mana when it procs

so for icemages that just spam frostbolt it procs every 2,5 * 1/0.02 = 100 secs

edit:

so actually it adds 630 mana within 115 sec. compared to an item with mana tic over 5 secs it would be:

630 * 5/115 = 27 mana every 5 secs

maybe not to shabby. although im not so sure about the 60 mana/s tic i assumed above. i dont run an addon that calculates this anymore, so its just a guess. therefore u might wanna enter "ur" value there ...

Edited, Fri Jul 15 04:32:55 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

gonna try to get 2 of these for 4%

Comment by Allakhazam

-it stacks with meditation (115% - after 5 sek 100% = its more effective while casting with meditation skill)
-wands can proc it! even cooking and fishing
-the effekt is not magic = not despellable

Comment by Allakhazam

im also sure this one is better on priests than mages, b/c priests seem to have more mana issues, and mages right now arent casting scorches in raid instances but frostbolts instead, with higher casting time which means less procs

but there are so many priests bidding and rolling for briarwood reed or talisman of ephemaral power (which are clearly better on mages than priests), so i just not care about priest tbh

Comment by Allakhazam

I just got the deck but gotta wait for the faire to do it...

Lot of ppl have been saying this card is underpowered but I disagree. I basically only care about Molten Core and then only care about mana during boss fights. There might be better trinkets out there but this is damn valuable in my eyes cause I've seen the boss fights where a priest such as myself is literally spamming instacast dispels for what seems like 10minutes straight and spamming instacast heal over times... That said I know it'll proc a helluvalot. Then couple this concept with the fact that if I completely run out of mana, using your wand will also proc it...

There might be better stuff out there but this will definitely be an upgrade for me.

Comment by Allakhazam

All i see is mages and priests $%^&*ing...what about this trinket for warlocks? They do a lot of different curses and spells especially in instances.

All i have left to get is the Ace.

Edited, Thu Jan 5 11:52:45 2006

Comment by Allakhazam

If any of you EVER have seen these wierd cards....then tell me. I got em.

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=Nina.jpg

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=Diseap.jpg

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=Void.jpg

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=ThorpTilPhillip.jpg

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=UlsakTilDavid.jpg

http://s177.photobucket.com/albums/w231/Hellbull_Grunt/?action=view&current=HellbullWoWTCGCard.jpg

Comment by Allakhazam

The real problem is, that there are now SOO many trinkets in the game that don't suck.

This is one of them.

BWL has an epic trinket for each class, Briarwood Reed drops off of Jed runewatcher, theres the class specific DM trinket, the Eye of the Beast, Burst of Knowledge, Mindtap, and then this.

What to use? :o

This is awsome for a boss fight in which you are always casting, I would probably replace it with my current eye of the beast just for boss fights.

<mage>

Comment by Allakhazam

im also a idiot shaman, clarify if im stupid or not. what do u guys feel

Comment by Allakhazam

I got this 2 days ago.. and from what i figure it also stacks with magearmor.
I have roughly 90 mana/tick normaly. and about 30 when casting. but when this procs i get 120ish mana/tick.
Another thing is.. this can proc to any tradeskill it seems. It proced for me when i was making Enchanted Thorium Bars for a guildie ^^
Maybe its a bug, maybe not.(tho tradeskill stuff is listed as "You have learned a new spell" in the general window)

Comment by Allakhazam

Is this good for hunters?

Comment by Allakhazam

Okay, I'm a NE priest with 6/8 Prophecy and some other good stuff. I've been farming gold on my 60 hunter, and I have a large income now. I just can't decide whether to go and buy my epic mount, or get the Ace of Beasts, and make the deck. I'm having a real hard time deciding, you might think I'm silly, but if someone could give me a word of advice, please do. Thanks a lot.

Comment by Allakhazam

Hunter Trinket

Comment by Allakhazam

was wondering if this trinket will proc with instant cast spells.

Comment by Allakhazam

Have done very little testing, but I believe this trinket makes Druid Innervate twice as powerful, giving 800% regen - but not for a full 15secs, only half that. (No idea why it did this, but good enough still)

My spirit stats wasn't important, took off all x mana/5sec gear so I could monitor ct_regen properly for trying this trinket and Innervate

Edited, Thu Sep 8 07:43:33 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

I think many of you fail to see the formula on how items with proc % work. Proc % in WoW doesn't necessarily work the way many of you seem to think.

There are -many- trinkets in WoW with a 2% proc chance, heck, look at the trinket that has a 2% chance to increase attributes by 25, and that goes off very often.

Many of you seem to be taking the general consensus that low % proc items are somehow automatically divided by a raw number and a guaranteed proc.

Do you really think that the trinket will proc only once every 50 heals? I challenge any of you to say yes after the first week of August, because I guarantee you that you are wrong. The rates trinkets proc at are much more an often occurance in bursts of time than anything else.

Comment by Allakhazam

Lets say a typical bossfight is 10 minutes, mindtap talisman gives 1320 mana.
Lets say you could cast 40 spells and it procs. Normal spirit regen level 60 = 100mp a tick is 50 mana a sec = 750 mana in 15 seconds.

Mindtap talisman owns this by far.

The longer the bossfight the crappier this trinket is. Plus that its not reliable.

maybe when spamming level 1 flash heal with inspiration this trinket could have its use.....but thats a may may be

Comment by Allakhazam

Blue Dragon or mindtap? The answer is simple.

If you have high spirit (200+) this is better. If you have low spirit (< 150).

A proc on this means an extra 500-750 mana if you take full advantage of the proc.

To use this well, do the following. When you are low/out of mana wand with a fast wand. Once the blue dragon procs (yes wands proc it), cast all you can for 10-15 seconds (anything past 10 seconds will put you in no-spirit land for a bit).

However, for an epic, it should be a higher % Proc. A mindtap is so much easier to get and almost as good, sometimes better.

Comment by Allakhazam

I'd like to ask you if it is possible to equip 2 different darkmoon cards for example:

Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon
AND
Darkmoon Card: Twisting Nether

I know they're unique but thats for the exact same card isnt it?

Comment by Allakhazam

Flash heal may be only a 1.5 sec cast, but it costs 380 mana. Ratio that out and if it were a 2.5 cast it would cost 633.3E mana.

On a mage your Frostbolts {2.5 cast of course} only cost 260. So a mage will be casting a LOT more, and since a mage is pure damage (as opposed to healing every now and then) they'll be casting continuously and it will proc MUCH more on a mage in long fights (where it's actually useful) such as Onyxia.

So.....Definitely a mage item :)

Comment by Allakhazam

Triggered with every trade skill like when u make enchant or loot herb plant... while u conjure food and when u make portal too =))))

Edited, Tue Apr 11 09:02:37 2006

Comment by Allakhazam

I'm normally using the DM priest trinket + the onyxia shard.
I've had this trinket for quite a while though and tonight I tested it.
I replaced the shard.
We were doing an AQ40 run and it didn't procc more than max 2 times before the twins (about 3hrs raidtime).
I was just saying in our priestchannel how worthless it was but I kept it on for the twinsfight. It procced 5 or 6 times during that fight (a ~15 mins fight) and regenerated more mana for me than the shard ever would.

I'm still not sure if I should use it or not. Seems you have to be a bit lucky with the proccs for it to pay off.

Comment by Allakhazam

I one of the better guilds in the EU and pretty much all our priests have this now.

We have done excessive testing which involves using it on various raids, pvp and boss's such as ragnaros and razergore (we have them on farm).

In MC it procs for me countless times. I have duel mindtaps usually, the mana regen from them is good, but u do not feel it, however when aura of blue dragon procs it is 3 flash heals within 5secs, also if it procs when u are about to rest on healing rotation, the mana regen is huge, esp with a soulkeeper with +20 sprit (hitting 350 to 360 spirit +15% talent regen).

For someone who hasnt got much money and doesnt raid the whole of MC, duel mind taps are alot better, but this truely is the hand of justice of casters (HoJ being sword spec rogues or any warriors best friend)

Comment by Allakhazam

Well, this thing really needs a buff to state itself epic. Now it just removes the 5s spirit penalty.

4% proc to get 150% manaregen and 100% manaregen while casting. Like Innervate but a very nerfed Innervate.

Only then would it become epic in my book.

Edited, Mon Oct 10 06:20:19 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

Regardless of gear the proc-chance on this is way to low to replace a mindtap/shard.
Dont waste any gold in getting this.

Comment by Allakhazam

Basically, if your amount of spirit sucks, this card will suck for you. Since it just allows you to have normal mana regen while casting for 15 seconds (plus any bonuses such as Meditation and 3-piece Trans bonus for a priest, to 130% regen), this item goes off of your spirit.

It's great for priests with high-end gear, and I'm sure druids with proper talents and 3-piece Stormrage would like it too. But for mages, warlocks, or any other mana-using class for which spirit is a limited attribute, you're most likely not going to see an "epic-quality" proc from this trinket since when it procs you won't regen near as much as someone with alot more spirit and regen bonuses.

It says it has a 2% proc rate, but after spam testing for an hour one day I discovered that it's more like a 4% proc rate, which is fairly often given the number of insta-casts such as Renew that someone will be using in a raid.

Comment by Allakhazam

Does it even help hunters?

Comment by Allakhazam

If an arcane explosion hits 5 mobs - will it then give me 10 % proc chance or still only 2 % ?

...And does it stack with BoW and mage armor ?

/lvl 60 mage

Edited, Tue Oct 11 06:27:05 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

OK, I have this card. It DOES have to ability to proc with instant casts, as some people have asked, I have had it go off with Moonfire and Rejuvenation.

It has a 2% chance to proc each cast. You have to take each cast as a seperate event, you can't just say "if I cast it 50 times it is bound to go off". No. It may go off every time. Or it may not go off at all for 500 casts. After saying that though, I have found that is usually procs every third or fourth spell cast.

I have found that it is an awesome little trinket for higher end instances, as when it goes off, my mana is regenerating while I am still throwing a heal on the MT = more mana to throw around during the fight.

I got about 4 of the cards in drops, including the elusive Ace from The Beast (also got Finkle's Skinner at the same time, skinned the beast and got Pristine Hide of the Beast, yay for me!) so it only cost me about 25g in total. Completely worth it in my opinion.

Hope this cleared up some issues.

Edited, Sat Apr 29 10:27:35 2006

Comment by Allakhazam

This trinket seems like it was designed for priests, but..
The proc % is too low imho, its only use is in a pve enviroment during a boss encounter. And even then, a chance of 2% is not something to rely on.
Maybe if you could get 2, but its unique.. a mistake.
Overal, the effort to collect all cards to get this is not worth the trouble.

Edited, Fri Jul 15 09:29:24 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

This is not a Mage Trinket its a Priest Trinket.
Flashheal only has a Casttime of 1.5 sek so it procs every 75 sec.

Comment by Allakhazam

during the magmadar encounter i use about 30k mana .. mostly flash heals and renew with a ratio of 3:1. i guess the trinket would proc 1-3 times. with my current spirit setup i would get 1400 mana per proc. mindtap talisman regenerates about 1000 mana in this encouter. but i still wonder whether it stacks with meditation.

Comment by Allakhazam

.

Edited, Tue Jul 26 03:16:16 2005

Comment by Allakhazam

im a mage with the deck.. is it worth it for a mage? we have mage armor, mana gems, and evocate, which ive always found 2 be enough mana

Comment by Allakhazam

I think this card is really good for Boss fights - that's the only time I equip it. But for those fights it is simply awesome.

For example during long fights such as Hakkar, it'll typically proc 4-6 times adding up to 2400-3600 mana.

For trash mobs, or general fighting I don't use it but during end games boss fights it really shines!

Comment by Erethzium

Does not have an ICD. I've had it proc and then proc again while the first proc was still active.

Comment by XiZ0r

As a paladin in classic I figured I'd give this a go as the BiS items up until p6 has a lot of spirit on them. This paired with spirit being an unused stat.

Going with the previous calculations of roughly a 1/5 uptime it's a bit hit or miss.

On paper it looks fantastic with full bwl gear around 27mp5. In reality it is really unreliable, but so is crit for paladin.

Sure try this out if it fits your playstyle (FoL spamming). But don't expect miracles.

I'm still going to use it but if you have doubts I wouldn't recommend.

Comment by lakiozoon

If I land a spell just before the Aura of the Blue Dragon ends, will I still remain out of 5sr after it ends?

Did some observations on my mana ticks and it seems that:
1. You get out of 5sr instantly when it procs.
2. Once the buff ends you will enter the 5sr depending when your last spell was cast (even during the aura).

So there really is no way to play with it (extending it) using Inner Focus once it ends:/

Do correct me if i'm wrong.

Comment by webphut74

I love mine. I have weak auras 2 set up to show me when it turns on. I am a restoration druid and its adds a little more fun to healing. if you can afford to get all the cards together it is a really fun trinket.

Comment by howa003

>>> BONUS MP5 FOR CLASSIC TBC (2.5.1) <<<

Known information.
- 2 % proc chance from ANY spell (harmful, direct heal, HoT, crafting items etc.),
- no internal cooldown,
- causes full mana regeneration rate (i.e. regeneration rate out of 5 second rule) for 15 seconds even when inside the 5 second rule.

General formula for the calculation of MP5 bonus provided by the trinket.
The formula for the calculation of the MP5 provided by the trinket is:
MP5bonus = (0,02*SPM)*(MR-MP5)*(15/60),
where:
SPM is number of spells cast per minute,
MR is mana regeneration rate (per 5 seconds) when outside of 5 second rule,
MP5 is mana regeneration rate (per 5 seconds) when inside of 5 second rule.

The first bracket expresses the chance that the trinket will proc.
The second bracket expresses the increase of MP5 during the trinket buff.
The third bracket expresses the fact that the trinket buff last only 15 seconds out of the 60 second in a minute.

As the SPM is greatly affected by player's healing style, and MR and MP5 are highly dependent on equip of the player, exact value of MP5 bonus provided by the trinket cannot be generally given. A value of MP5 bonus provided by the trinket for a self-buffed T4 BiS geared resto druid is derived below.

Value of MP5 bonus provided by the trinket for a self-buffed T4 BiS geared resto druid.
Known:
MP5bonus = (0.02*SPM)*(MR-MP5)*(15/60).

Assumptions:
SPM = 30
MP5 from equip, enchants and gems = 86.
Self-buffed intellect = 405.
Self-buffed spirit = 468.
MP5 overall (equip, enchants, gems and talents) = 217.8
MR = 525.2

Results:
MP5bonus = (0.02*30)*(525.2-217.8)*(15/30) = 46.11 MP5.

View in 3D Find upgrades...Links

Quick Facts

Screenshots

Videos

Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon

Item Level 66
Binds when equipped
Unique-Equipped

Trinket

Requires Level 60
Equip: 2% chance on successful spellcast to allow 100% of your Mana regeneration to continue while casting for 15 sec. (Proc chance: 2%)

Sell Price: 10

Darkmoon Card: Blue Dragon

Related

Contribute